Friday, February 19, 2010

Converting to Concierge Medicine in Today’s Economy—Economic Suicide or Salvation?

“How,” you may ask “could converting to a concierge medical practice model help me in these economic times?” If done correctly, converting to a concierge or retainer-based practice model could help you offset your losses in fee-for-service revenue by “segmenting your market”.
“Market Segmentation” is the process of developing two or more distinct marketing propositions to address the differing perceived needs of customers, or potential customers, in a market, with each marketing proposition addressing the members of a group, or segment, who have similar views regarding needs or interests.
In our world, market segmentation is accomplished by: 1) providing to patients who value highly personalized preventative care, immediate physician availability, and an ongoing relationship with a trusted doctor the ability to access unprecedented levels of care and service; and 2) continuing to provide standard levels of care and service to patients who place more importance on price than on service. Market segmentation enables your practice to give patients what they desire. While we believe that one physician cannot successfully offer two distinct levels of care to different patient groups; you can hire a physician’s assistant or nurse practitioner to serve as the principal interface with non-concierge patient, or you can hire an associate MD to treat those patients in the broader context of your practice.
So, back to the original question. We believe that segmenting your market to deliver the care that your patients desire not only does not constitute economic suicide
but rather represents an excellent risk mitigation strategy. Unless you have the “perfect practice”, undertaking an all or nothing conversion (terminating your relationship with any patient who chooses not to join your retainer practice) to concierge medicine could entail additional risks in today’s economic climate.

Changing Our Disease Care System To A Health Care System

Now that health care reform has been put on the back burner, maybe it is time to discuss what health care reform should really look like. Although we talk about a "health care" system and health care reform, what we're actually talking about is a "disease care" system and disease care reform. Doctors of modern western medicine are trained to treat disease with drugs and surgery. They are not trained to keep people healthy.
At medical school, we doctors are taught how to treat the symptoms of disease, rather than how to prevent disease in the first place. For example, throughout our training we receive very few lectures on nutrition, despite the fact that diet is fundamental to good health. Nor are we trained in other lifestyle modalities that help keep people well, such as exercise and relaxation therapies. We are taught nothing about the wisdoms of alternative medical systems that have been helping other cultures for centuries.
I will be the first to acknowledge that modern western medicine and science have made phenomenal advances. These improvements alleviate pain and suffering and save lives every day. Better treatment of trauma and burns for example, or the management of acute medical and surgical emergencies, are among the miracles of modern life. We have drugs today that, when used appropriately, work wonders. We are indeed blessed to have modern western medicine in our arsenal, and for disasters like the Haiti earthquake, this kind of medicine is life saving.
The problem is that although most of us are not permanently in a health "crisis", this crisis care model is being used to treat our every health problem or symptom - as if it is the only health care model we have. Most of us are not sick enough to be in hospital, and by far the majority of people who visit their doctor, do so for ongoing chronic problems like diabetes, heart disease and obesity - or less-defined ailments like joint pains, back pains, fatigue and headaches. Western medicine's solutions to these problems are drugs and surgery.
But apart from antibiotics, which can kill the bug causing the problem, most drugs treat symptoms and not causes. Similarly, surgery usually addresses the symptoms and not the causes. For instance, bypass surgery, although often life saving, does not address the underlying reasons for why one's arteries are getting blocked in the first place. And in the case of both drugs and surgery there are often significant side effects, which are then addressed with even more drugs, resulting in many patients being on multiple drugs at the same time. But these drugs are powerful agents interacting with very complex systems. Often the first one or two drugs have been prescribed to treat the original problem and the other five to 10 are treating the side effects caused by the first two drugs or the interactions of the other drugs. Clearly this understanding of how to actually cure disease is incomplete.
The tragedy is that most of the chronic problems that most people endure can so often be cured with diet, lifestyle and behavior changes and supplements. Drugs - along with their potentially-unpleasant or even lethal side effects - are often not necessary. Unfortunately it does not suit the drug industry to give patients a drug that cures or eliminates the problem. It is much more lucrative to use drugs to simply manage a patient's symptoms, ensuring that he or she stays on them for life, instead of eliminating the disease. Examples of this would bestatins and anti-hypertensives.
What we should now really strive for is a health care system that shows patients how to stay well with a properly preventive approach. In fact what we call "preventive medicine" in the modern western model - pap smears, breast exams and certain blood tests - are really "early detection" measures. I am not saying these tests are unnecessary, but they are not teaching patients how to stay healthy or prevent the diseases they are being screened for. We need a complete rethink and overhaul of what early detection really means and implies.
A true health care system would incorporate the "disease care" model as part of the system. I most certainly would not encourage a patient with a medical emergency to see a nutritionist or acupuncturist. But by the same token, these modalities need to be seen as an important part of a much more comprehensive health care system.
My 30 years of experience as a doctor have shown me that in the areas where western medicine is weak - such as chronic disease and disease prevention - a combination of other modalities and systems actually excel; and where western medicine is particularly helpful, these other modalities are not as effective. It's about taking the best of both and going beyond the limitations of each and melding them into a new combination that works.
This means that western medicine should be used for crisis care, but for chronic disease we should find the root cause of the problem and uproot it - instead of merely suppressing the symptoms. We should look for the underlying metabolic processes that have gone awry or the underlying dysfunctions present. We then need to try to correct these safely, effectively and without side effects.
We must use the objective information we get from blood tests, X rays, MRIs and so on. But we need to consider the actual patient or person as well, by taking into account subjective information too: feelings, intuition, attitudes, belief systems and relationships.
In a true health care system, we must use modern western medicine for what it is good at - crisis care, acute medical and surgical emergencies - and natural, non-toxic and non-invasive therapies whenever possible. The most effective ways of preventing and treating most chronic diseases are diet, supplements, exercise, stress management and other benign modalities. And herein lies the rub. Although guidance may be helpful, lifestyle changes can't be imposed from above - they have to come from you. There is no greater reward than being the master of your own health.

Monday, February 15, 2010

Why primary care doctors need to practice insurance free medicine

I never thought I would be in academic medicine for so long.

When I was hired about 12 year ago, I figured I would stay in academics for a few years and then join a private practice Internal Medicine group. Now, I can’t even fathom that idea. One of the reasons I have stayed at my institution for so long is that I love teaching and the academic environment.

However, a second reason is that the “real world” for primary care medicine is a scary one. As a salaried employee in a large practice, I am somewhat sheltered from the harsh realities of running a business in the current health care environment. Yet, I hear horror stories from my colleagues in the community that are struggling to survive. With reimbursement rates from insurances so low, and administrative burdens so high, many older physicians have retired and younger physicians have adopted new models of delivering care. These have various names such as “concierge medicine” or “boutique medicine.”

Though I have no intention of leaving any time soon, I know that the current model of a small group of primary care physicians who accept insurance is simply not sustainable. Yet, I have a hard time imagining myself practicing in one of these new models, or even attracting patients to my practice. Retainer medicine is one model, where primary care physicians are able to see a much smaller panel size (and thus increase access) by charging patients an annual fee, which ranges from hundreds to thousands of dollars.

Though the model makes financial sense, the word “retainer” sounds too legalese for me and likely not easily understood by the lay public. I would prefer something like “membership fee” similar to something would pay to join a club. However, “membership medicine” or “club medicine” just doesn’t seem to have a good ring.

“Boutique” practices often use a retainer model, but boutique can also refer to primary care physicians who charge for extra services such as laser hair removal or Botox injections. There are many primary care physicians who still take insurance that have started using these kind of practices or have found other ways to meet their bottom line, such as selling nutritional supplements. Though there is no question that the public has a demand for these services, providing them for a fee as a primary care physician seems to carry some conflict of interest, since none of these services show any benefit in overall health.

“Concierge medicine” is another term used with retainer models and boutique practices. This implies some sort of preferential treatment, but also usually is associated with “executive physicals” and a battery of unnecessary testing and high technology that again provides little in the way of proven health benefits.

Some physicians have continued to practice normally, but simply do not accept insurance. They have figured out that they can sustain a primary care practice if they simply refuse to accept the substantially reduced rates that insurance companies give them. These are often referred to as cash only practices. Yet, the term “cash only” seems to imply (at least to me) something shady or under the table. In addition, most patients who see cash only physicians, pay for these services using a credit card, making the name somewhat illogical.

However, the reason that all these new models of medicine exist boils down to one single reason: health insurance. Rates from insurance companies are so low, that the only way a primary care physician can make ends meet is to increase volume to the point that both access and care delivery suffer substantially. In addition, the administrative headaches which include fighting to get tests/medicines covered and arguing over claims once submitted, make the practice of medicine less than enjoyable.

The oft-quoted study (that I co-authored) showing that only 2% of medical students are interested in primary care internal medicine, is often used to support the argument that primary care physicians need to be paid more. While the need to substantially reduce the growing income discrepancy between primary care physicians and specialists is critically important, the study actually showed that educational experience, nature of patient care and lifestyle were the primary factors influencing career choice, not income. This was regardless of students’ medical school debt. In other words, it was more about the hassles of primary care medicine and less about the how much money they would make, that led students away from careers in primary care.

Thus, I think a term that I would like to propose for use in further discussions of newer ways of practicing primary care is “insurance free medicine.” The term “insurance free medicine” captures the essence of the newer models of primary care. Patients have certainly seen their premiums and deductibles increase and can probably relate quite well to reasons why a doctor would not accept insurance.

Insurance free primary care practices could certainly adopt retainer membership fees and promote improved access, but eliminating terms like “boutique,” “concierge,” and “cash only” might help eliminate the notion that primary medical care without insurance is somehow tainted or only for the super-wealthy. Previously, I discussed that without substantial changes, primary care will soon go the way of psychiatry in that patients who use their insurance to see a psychiatrist get one kind of care (very brief visits, mostly management by a non-physician) and those who pay their psychiatrist out-of-pocket get the kind of care that we see in TV and the movies.

With more frequent use of the term “insurance free medicine,” patients might start realizing that if they continue to pay their primary physician using their health care insurance, they should expect even briefer visits, longer waits to get in, seeing non-physicians, and greater delays getting a return phone call or results back.

Though I have no immediate plans to leave the world of academia any time soon, I could certainly see starting an insurance-free practice if I ever did.

Presented by : Dr Mintz

Matthew Mintz is an internal medicine physician

Friday, February 12, 2010

CONCIERGE MEDICINE: CONVENIENT AND AFFORDABLE CARE

Concierge medicine - boutique medicine - membership practice - retainer practice - personal medicine - direct care: no matter what you call it, the cash-pay practice is on the rise.

The Society for Innovative Medical Practice Design (SIMPD) has estimated there are over 5000 concierge practices in the US (up from 500 in 2005), and according to the CDC as far back as 2006, 11% of practices were cash-only (I assume this includes all specialties).

In the face of (1) a primary care physician shortage, (2) healthcare reform that is going to up the ante with numbers of insured patients needing doctors, (3) physician exhaustion and discouragement at the "primary care lifestyle" (seeing one patient every 8-10 minutes) and (4) the focus on developing Medical Homes, I'm beginning to wonder if the concierge-style practice might be the answer!

Who wins with this model?

the physician who is able to limit his or her practice to 600-800 families/individuals, provide care in a way that maintains the passion for doctoring, make an acceptable living and enjoy a reasonable lifestyle. Even though the numbers suggest that concierge doctor tend to make slightly less money than their counterparts in traditional practices, their quality of life appears to improve dramatically.
the patient with a health savings account/high deductible insurance plan whose health is monitored closely and conveniently (?email consults ?phone consults - less risky when you know your patients well), who gets his or her questions answered thoroughly and whose out-of-pocket expenses my be reduced overall
primary care as a specialty, as the options become much more attractive
employers who help their employees invest in their health by making it possible for them to become patients of the Medical Home concierge practice
those insurance companies that "get it" - that their next successful product isn't a plain vanilla health insurance policy. Instead it's designed to encouraged patients to engage in preventive care, absorb routine care costs themselves (with HSAs etc.), and opt instead for affordable coverage to pay for more costly and unexpected services
Of course, it behooves concierge medicine practitioners to use resources wisely, familiarizing themselves with evidence-based guidelines and avoiding the temptation to soak the rich with Presidential Physicals that include annual "everything is scanned and worked up" studies! And it will serve them well to pick up a few coaching skills -- the ones I wish I had truly had and used as a family doc in practice!

Monday, February 8, 2010

Preventive Medicine Education

Preventive medicine education is a perfect compliment to healthcare providers who work in the public health sector. Part of a fellowship program, preventive medicine education offers the most up-to-date knowledge and training by leading experts of the field.

Medical students who successfully graduate from medical school or medical residents may apply for a fellowship in preventive medicine education; however, qualification requisites vary depending on individual educational aspirations.

Preventive medicine education curriculums may encompass a broad spectrum of training and academic programs, which may include disease prevention and health promotion; control and prevention of infectious disease; observation, immunization and children’s health; community health; quality improvement of healthcare and patient protection; responsiveness to bioterrorism and disasters; local, federal and state public health practices; and occupational and environmental health medicine.

Furthermore, preventive medicine education programs and courses may vary in duration and cost; and are usually offered at traditional medical universities and colleges.

As an added note, preventive medicine education in the alternative medicine field integrates wellness programs and training to naturopaths, holistic practitioners, and other related medical specialists as well.

Article Source: http://EzineArticles.com/?expert=C._Bailey_Lloyd

WHAT'S THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN 'PREVENTIVE' MEDICINE AND 'DIRECT' PRIMARY CARE?

Direct primary care (DPC) is a term often linked to its companion in health care, 'concierge medicine.' Although the two terms are similar and belong to the same family, concierge medicine is a term that fully embraces or 'includes' many different health care delivery models, direct primary care being one of them.

Similarities

DPC practices, similar in philosophy to their preventive medicine lineage - bypass insurance and go for a more 'direct' financial relationship with patients and also provide comprehensive care and preventive services for an affordable fee. However, DPC is only one branch in the family tree of concierge medicine.

DPC, like concierge health care practices, remove many of the financial barriers to 'accessing' care whenever care is needed. There are no insurance co-pays, deductibles or co-insurance fees. DPC practices also do not typically accept insurance payments, thus avoiding the overhead and complexity of maintaining relationships with insurers, which can consume as much as $0.40 of each medical dollar spent (See Sources Below).

Differences

According to sources (see below) DPC is a 'mass-market variant of concierge medicine, distinguished by its low prices.' Simply stated, the biggest difference between 'direct primary care' and retainer based practices is that DPC takes a low, flat rate fee whereas omodels, (although plans may vary by practice) - usually charge an annual retainer fee and promise more 'access' to the doctor.

According to Concierge Medicine Today, the first official news outlet for this marketplace, both health care delivery models are providing affordable, cost-effective executive healthcare plans to thousands of patients across the U.S. MDNewsToday is also the only known organization that is officially tracking and collecting data on these practices and the physicians -- including the precise number of concierge physicians and practices throughout the U.S.

"This primary care business model [direct primary care] gives these type of providers the time to deliver more personalized care to their patients and pursue a comprehensive medical home approach," said Norm Wu, CEO of Qliance Medical Management based in Seattle, Washington. "One in which the provider's incentives are fully aligned with the patient's incentives."

Article Source: http://EzineArticles.com/?expert=Michael_Tetreault

Is Concierge Medicine the answer to the primary care shortage?

Concierge medicine - boutique medicine - membership practice - retainer practice - personal medicine - direct care: no matter what you call it, the cash-pay practice is on the rise.

The Society for Innovative Medical Practice Design (SIMPD) has estimated there are over 5000 concierge practices in the US (up from 500 in 2005), and according to the CDC as far back as 2006, 11% of practices were cash-only (I assume this includes all specialties).

In the face of (1) a primary care physician shortage, (2) healthcare reform that is going to up the ante with numbers of insured patients needing doctors, (3) physician exhaustion and discouragement at the "primary care lifestyle" (seeing one patient every 8-10 minutes) and (4) the focus on developing Medical Homes, I'm beginning to wonder if the concierge-style practice might be the answer!

Who wins with this model?

  • the physician who is able to limit his or her practice to 600-800 families/individuals, provide care in a way that maintains the passion for doctoring, make an acceptable living and enjoy a reasonable lifestyle. Even though the numbers suggest that concierge physicians tend to make slightly less money than their counterparts in traditional practices, their quality of life appears to improve dramatically.
  • the patient with a health savings account/high deductible insurance plan whose health is monitored closely and conveniently (?email consults ?phone consults - less risky when you know your patients well), who gets his or her questions answered thoroughly and whose out-of-pocket expenses my be reduced overall
  • primary care as a specialty, as the options become much more attractive
  • employers who help their employees invest in their health by making it possible for them to become patients of the Medical Home concierge practice
  • those insurance companies that "get it" - that their next successful product isn't a plain vanilla health insurance policy. Instead it's designed to encouraged patients to engage in preventive care, absorb routine care costs themselves (with HSAs etc.), and opt instead for affordable coverage to pay for more costly and unexpected services
Of course, it behooves concierge doctor to use resources wisely, familiarizing themselves with evidence-based guidelines and avoiding the temptation to soak the rich with Presidential Physicals that include annual "everything is scanned and worked up" studies! And it will serve them well to pick up a few coaching skills -- the ones I wish I had truly had and used as a family doc in practice!